Digital health interventions (DHIs) hold immense promise to revolutionize and strengthen health systems. However, governments have struggled to scale up these interventions and to integrate them successfully into existing services. Complexities arise not only from the design of many DHIs, but also from their poor fit with broader system capacities and from the lack of enabling legal frameworks. They can also have unintended consequences, harm other health system components, exacerbate inequities and raise ethical issues – especially concerning data privacy and safety.
In light of these issues, the Alliance and the WHO Department of Digital Health and Innovations (DHI), with support from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, have launched an interdisciplinary project aimed at harnessing the power of digital interventions to strengthen health systems in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The project focuses on data solutions for primary care managers.
Ten research teams are being supported to:
- generate health policy and systems research on the role of digital data solutions for primary care managers in complex health systems in LMICs;
- stimulate learning and action on the integration of DHIs in health systems among policy- and decision-makers at the local and country levels; and
- disseminate the knowledge broadly to policy- and decision-makers to inform strategies for the integration of DHI in health systems in different LMIC contexts.
Dr Garrett Mehl, Unit Head of Digital Health Technology at WHO, noted that: “digital health interventions have become a prominent strategy for countries to address shortfalls in health systems performance and increase their potential to achieve universal health coverage. This project fills a critical gap in helping countries build capacity to use research to assess the implementation of these initiatives.”
“This is a key project for the Alliance at an important point in the development of digital health solutions,” added Dr Lorena Guerrero Torres, who is working on the technical side of the project for the Alliance. "By generating relevant health policy and systems research, facilitating collaboration and promoting knowledge exchange, we hope to support countries to understand better the intended and unintended consequences of adopting and implementing digital health interventions."
After an open call for proposals that drew 58 entries from 24 countries across all WHO regions, ten multidisciplinary research teams were selected to carry out this work in: Bhutan, Ethiopia, Georgia, Ghana, India, Indonesia, Pakistan and Zimbabwe.
The project kicked off with a framework harmonization workshop in Tunis, Tunisia, from 24-25 May 2023. The workshop sought to foster collaboration, ensure alignment and establish a robust foundation for research. During the two-day workshop, the ten research teams presented their proposals, identified commonalities and exchanged resources. See the map table below to learn more about the projects and institutions we are supporting in this project.
| Country | Grantee Institution | Project title |
|---|---|---|
| Bhutan | Institute of Health Partners | The role of the Bhutan Vaccine System (BVS) in strengthening the country’s health system and empowering people: lessons from Bhutan |
| Ethiopia | EMIRTA Institute of Research, Training and Development | The contribution and implementation challenges of the District Health Information Software 2 (DHIS2) within primary health care institutions in Ethiopia: a Mixed Methods Study |
| Georgia | National Center for Disease Control and Public Health (NCDC) | Evaluating the continuity of information for maternal care after the implementation of the digital Georgian Birth Registry |
| Ghana | Research and Grant Institute of Ghana (ReGIG) | Digital health information management in health care systems strengthening in Ghana |
| India | All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Kalyani | Evaluation of the current status and pilot testing package of interventions to improve the data ecosystem of the Reproductive and Child Health Portal, the Maternal and Child Tracking System, and the ANMOL (Auxiliary Nurse Midwife OnLine) app as a digital aid for health care managers |
| India | Indraprastha Institute of Information Technology Delhi (IIIT-Delhi) and WISH foundation | Strengthening managerial workflows with data-driven decision support in Sanjeevani Clinics in Madhya Pradesh, India |
| India | Sangath, Bhopal Hub | Digital Comprehensive Primary Healthcare Noncommunicable Disease (CPHC-NCD) Portal across primary health centres in Madhya Pradesh |
| Indonesia | Universitas Ahmad Dahlan | The role of the digital intervention SIMUNDU in strengthening health systems in Indonesia for PHC managers |
| Pakistan | Aga Khan University | Digital Decision Support System (DDSS) embedded within a larger telehealth platform in Pakistan: an assessment of feasibility, useability, acceptability, efficacy and improvement in quality of care for Sehat Kahani’s DDSS |
| Zimbabwe | University of Zimbabwe | The Electronic Health Records (E-HR)/IMPILO implementation and how it has contributed to health systems strengthening at primary care level in Zimbabwe |